Tremulous Forum

Community => Servers => Topic started by: tuple on February 03, 2009, 07:22:57 pm

Title: Flawed g3tremb2 in MG Repo
Post by: tuple on February 03, 2009, 07:22:57 pm
It seems that a bad version of the g3tremb2 archive has been found in the MG repo.  This version goes back years, and I suspect it originated from when the repo was originally set up.
I've obtained a copy from TJW's Site (http://tremulous.tjw.org/base/g3tremb2.pk3) which predates the MG repo and replaced the flawed version in the Repo with it.  I've found that other repo's are using the same version that was in the MG repo, which I suspect is the source of the file.

This map name is g3tremb2
also known as Infested Pump Station

md5sum of TJW's version:
fc00367511f661ccd2a1963ce4ed191e  g3tremb2.pk3

md5sum of MGs version:
979811158a943fa9b2484def76cca91c  g3tremb2.pk3

The only difference I've been able to determine is that the MG version will not unzip correctly from the command line:
unzip -l g3tremb2.pk3
reports an invalid archive.

Here's where the real problem crops up.

If you have the bad version on your server, and someone downloads the correct version they will be kicked from your server since the md5sums don't match.
Additionally, if you're server has the correct version and someone's client has the bad version, they will be kicked when their client tries to load it since the md5sums don't match.

I don't have any definitive proof, but I'm pretty sure that this is directly my fault  :-\  It appears to go back to when the MG repo was set up, and many of the maps where copied from my server at the time which had every map I could get my grubby little hands on.

Very sorry for the headache I've caused, if any.
Title: Re: Flawed g3tremb2 in MG Repo
Post by: Bissig on February 03, 2009, 08:42:34 pm
What's the (spelled out) map name?
Title: Re: Flawed g3tremb2 in MG Repo
Post by: Archangel on February 03, 2009, 09:30:51 pm
g3tremb2
Title: Re: Flawed g3tremb2 in MG Repo
Post by: Ingar on February 03, 2009, 09:32:00 pm
What's the (spelled out) map name?

Infested Pump Station
ported by Xiane

I had to load it to find out, but I have played this one before ;)
Title: Re: Flawed g3tremb2 in MG Repo
Post by: Bissig on February 03, 2009, 09:35:08 pm
What's the (spelled out) map name?

Infested Pump Station
ported by Xiane

I had to load it to find out, but I have played this one before ;)

Ah, that one. Haven't played it for at least 6 month.

Thanks!
Title: Re: Flawed g3tremb2 in MG Repo
Post by: tuple on February 03, 2009, 10:11:52 pm
I've updated the original post to include the map name and the common name.

I may have been hasty in worrying about this, in that there is a map-g3tremb2 as well, which "may" be the "newer" version.  In as much as they are years old.
Title: Re: Flawed g3tremb2 in MG Repo
Post by: Undeference on February 04, 2009, 01:50:18 am
I've obtained a copy from TJW's Site (http://tremulous.tjw.org/base/g3tremb2.pk3)
I expect that link will stop working in the not too distant future.

I may have been hasty in worrying about this, in that there is a map-g3tremb2 as well, which "may" be the "newer" version.
I don't see that name (http://betaserv.tk/paklist.html) anywhere.
Title: Re: Flawed g3tremb2 in MG Repo
Post by: tuple on February 04, 2009, 01:15:36 pm
Damn.  I saw the map-g3tremb2.pk3 and, of course, didn't take note of its location.  I'm retracing my steps to find it.  When I do I'll md5sum it and post.
Title: Re: Flawed g3tremb2 in MG Repo
Post by: Paradox on February 05, 2009, 02:44:59 am
That map used to play almost daily on SST.

The version on Tremcentral is a good version, i just downloaded it this afternoon.
http://tremcentral.com/base/map-gloom3t.pk3

That was uploaded by Xiane himself, who was a big member of SST for a long time, so it should be valid. If not, i can email him and get another copy.