I guess you must be L33T at searching then because even with the title i couldn't find it in the first 7 pages using "rating system", or "point system"....
Thank you for finding that for me though.
There are differences in what I was saying and what they were saying. I still think points is a good idea based on criterea similar to what I said and I do not think it is too complicated etc. You can say "how long a building survives isn't a measure of a good builder" but you can also say that about kills.. i'm not saying replace kills, i'm saying having a points system is still more representative than kills, and will give more credit where its due..
I've seen this work in some games, a lot of them will give points to builders, even if its only a mod.
Proximity of kills to base encourages players to leave their base etc...
Killing enemies while in a group away from your base maybe could give you a teamwork point. Maybe negative points for feeding.. etc..
But i'm not going to hijack this guys thread.. I do think its a good idea though.