Why don't you guys use GrangerHub's map rating system for the evaluation? Have the players decide on the winner. When your maps are ready, they can be placed in the rotation on the GrangerPub & GrangerClub servers for one week, and the players can rate the maps on the website at that time. Whichever map in the competition has the highest overall rating by the end of the week (besides the winning mapper winning whatever prize(s) you guys agree to), will remain on the rotion for a month, and if the players still love the map at the end of the month, the map will remain in the rotation permanently. As a side note, I recommend that you guys limit the file sizes, so that you don't piss off some of the judges who still use older clients and have lower download rates. Also it would be good to have the maps playable. If anyone else would like to be in this competition, now is the time to speak up.